ICANN has developed a few mechanisms for dealing with disputes, whether or not the disputes are trademark based. First, if two applicants are simply applying for the same gTLD, the gTLD will, generally, be delegated on a first-come, first-serve basis, unless neither applicant has completed the application process. If the latter case occurs, ICANN will determine the winner based a set of four ownership-based criteria. In the event of a tie on the criteria, the gTLD will be auctioned to the highest bidder. ICANN hopes that many disputes will be resolved by the applicants themselves and plans to notify any applicants in contention in order to facilitate this process. However, once an applicant is granted ownership of a gTLD, the applicant may decide, at their discretion, who may register on their TLD.
Second, ICANN has collaborated with WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization) to ensure that ICANN's procedures adequately protect intellectual property holders. Although ICANN is not requiring applicants to own a trademark in order to apply for a gTLD, ICANN has stated that it will take any trademarks, registered anywhere in the world, into consideration when evaluating gTLD applications. ICANN is also likely to publish any applications that are chosen for evaluation, thus affording trademark owners the opportunity to protest an application, but it appears that such objections will be somewhat expensive. Further, it appears that ICANN and WIPO are working towards either expanding the current Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) to include new gTLDs or developing a UDRP-type program specifically tailored for the new gTLDs.
Finally, ICANN has implemented separate procedures for the adult top level domain names (.xxx). Many companies believe, and rightfully so, that being associated with adult material might adversely affect their trademark or brand. As such, ICANN has granted ICM Registry the .xxx TLD and ICM is allowing trademark owners to file applications requesting that their trademark be prevented from being registered on this TLD. The application period for this type of application is set to be open from September 7, 2011, to October 31, 2011.
Each of these processes has nuances and exceptions associated with it, so it is important to consult an attorney before applying for a gTLD or attempting to resolve a gTLD dispute. For more information about ICANN's dispute resolution procedures please consult ICANN's guidebook on www.icann.org.
